<meta name="google-site-verification" content="A0Hkdwjhm5g-iCzoctZ4mYl3nGpRp1x56PWznB-hC3U" />

Maastricht University

Conference Report: Gender and Occupation

Hannah Cogan, King’s College London

The theme of gender is significant in many facets of everyday life under occupation. Each paper that handled this theme was in some way concerned with how gendered hierarchies play out in the unequal power distributions between occupiers and occupied, and in the ways that post-conflict societies coming to terms with recent histories of violence develop new concepts of national identity and self-understanding. The panel, titled ‘Gendered Experiences of Occupation’, was chaired very graciously by Professor Sophie de Schaepdrijver, who cultivated a genuinely collaborative and supportive spirit in the room. All speakers remarked afterwards that the session was especially well-facilitated and enjoyable, with a high level of audience engagement and constructive questioning, facilitated by the chair’s decision to cap presentations at 10 minutes.

Leonie Bausch’s paper in this panel, based on her PhD research, examined the wide spectrum of intimate relationships that were formed between German women and French soldiers in the French occupation zone of postwar Germany, particularly considering how factors such as consent, coercion, and desire played out under the uneven power structures of a military occupation. Jana Aresin’s paper focused on the American occupation of post WW-II Japan, asking how the subject of gender, especially the role of women in society, was handled in the context of contemporary political discussions about Japanese national identity. Lara Green’s paper, based on her new and very promising research project, contrasted the gendered aspects of how female WW2 resistance fighters in the Netherlands and Soviet Union understood and portrayed themselves, and how these have persisted in the historical memory of women in resistance. My own paper, which summarised my PhD research, explored how German women undergoing denazification in the British occupation zone of Germany utilised the gendered tropes of passivity, religiosity, domesticity and naivety in the personal narratives that they produced for denazification purposes, asking how these have influenced popular memory of women in Nazi society.

The organisers’ efforts to include a panel dedicated exclusively to gendered perspectives on occupation studies were much appreciated by those who attended the ‘Gendered Experiences of Occupation’ panel. It was interesting to observe, however, that the panel comprised four female speakers and a female chair, that all the presented research focused on female subjects, and that the audience was about 75 per cent female. Indeed, one audience member commented on the above points during the Q&A. But concepts of gender are just as relevant to men as they are to women. It was therefore interesting to observe on other panels at the conference how men’s experiences of occupation could also be viewed through a gendered lens. This came across most clearly in the panel titled ‘Personal Relationships, Families and Children’. Although this panel comprised only two speakers, it was nevertheless highly informative, with many interesting overlaps between the two papers. Sarah Paterson’s paper on British children in the British sector of postwar occupied Berlin offered excellent idiosyncratic insight into the complicated dynamics within military families, who by the late 1940s might have been separated for several years, and who had to negotiate their reunification in the fraught setting of early postwar Berlin; wives, husbands and children all had to contend with this. Informed in part by her own childhood experiences of life in a British military family based in Berlin during the 1960s, Paterson focused in particular on children’s observations and understanding of their situation, emphasising their capacity to notice certain details that adults might miss. Peter Howson examined the lives and relationships of BAOR soldiers in Germany between 1947 and 1949, demonstrating how they intersected with occupation policies such as the requisitioning of German homes and marriage regulations. Howson’s analysis was informed significantly by his own experience of working as a military chaplain in Germany between the 1970s and 1990s and emphasised the theme of later cultural assimilation among British military personnel in Germany during their long presence in the country, particularly referencing the increasingly normalised practice of marriages between British men and German women. In both Paterson’s and Howson’s papers, the addition of personal insights based on their own lived experiences added much value to their research.

The panel titled ‘Entangled Experiences: Power, Colonialism and Gender in Occupied Germany and Japan’ was not grouped among the panels focused thematically on ‘gender’, but nevertheless gender did prove to be an important recurring theme in the research presented. Bettina Blum’s paper offered further analysis on the subject of relationships between occupiers and occupied in postwar Germany, with a focus on the ‘soft power’ of British wives and children who were expected to play important roles in ‘demonstrating democratic family life’ to Germans. In this respect, friendships between British and German children were usually tolerated, and sometimes even encouraged, whereas British and German women’s interactions were usually limited to ‘official contact zones’ such as Anglo-German discussion groups and wives’ clubs. Christine de Matos’ paper on women in post-WWII occupied Japan focused mainly on the relationships between Australian military wives and Japanese domestic servants and included one notable anecdote about an Australian wife’s foiled attempt to smuggle a Japanese servant to Australia in a suitcase. The theme of gender also appeared in the panel titled ‘Rethinking the Allied Occupation of Germany’, notably in Petra Wissbrock’s paper on British Kreis Resident Officers in post-WW II occupied Westphalia, whose assignment brief included the instruction that they should act as a model for the Germans, through their own behaviour, of the ideals of the ‘British gentleman’. Notions of normative masculine, gentlemanly behaviour also appeared in Valentin Bardet’s paper on Kreis Resident officers, informed in large part by class analysis.

In addition to learning about new research on the subject, the conference offered excellent opportunities for networking and collaboration among attendees, which will surely facilitate the production of new research.

 

Photo credits:

Cover picture:​ Photograph taken on Friday, January 8, 1943, during the celebration of Carl Frølich Hanssen’s 60th birthday in the Grand Hotel in Oslo, Norway. Frølich Hanssen, a former colonel and sports leader, was appointed General of the NS Labour Service (Norwegian Arbeidstjenesten, AT) in 1941, under the fascist Nasjonal Samling party in Nazi-Occupied Norway during World War 2.

Source: Wikimedia Commons This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

 

Hannah Cogan is a PhD Candidate at King’s College London, UK